? "Set Up an Existing Account" ? -- Re: UI mock-up - Account Setup Rev.2

Michael Peddemors michael at linuxmagic.com
Fri May 3 17:51:12 UTC 2019


Better get my two cents in then ;)

All in all a really nice user friendly presentation..

The ONLY thing I could suggest..
I always found the location and presentation of the 'Remember Password' 
could use a little love. I know that is so standard with many products, 
but in a large viewport, I don't think it belongs below the password 
field, and in a smaller viewport, does any one have any better ideas on 
how to visually present that?

And should it even be presented BEFORE the server is actually confirmed?

Once the server is found, confirmed, and BEFORE you hit 
connect/configure manually, might be the logical place to ask this 
question..

Or maybe even later.. after connect was confirmed..


On 2019-05-03 10:38 a.m., Alessandro Castellani wrote:
> Wow, this thread got a lot of answers.
> 
> Thank you so much for your suggestions and involvements. I'll take a 
> couple of days to collect your feedback, evaluate them, and improve the 
> mock-ups.
> 
> I'm glad to see that the majority of changes suggested are related to 
> content and not UI. I guess that means we all feel we're on the right path.
> 
> Here are some initial thoughts and general suggestions regarding your 
> feedback:
> 
>     /*WELCOME -- Configuring Thunderbird
>     *What do you want to do now?
>     1.Configure Thunderbird to work with an _existing_ email account?
>     2.Have Thunderbird create a _new_ email account and work with it?
>     3.Manually configure Thunderbird for more specialized uses?*
>     NOTE:*  You can return here later to configure Thunderbird to work
>     with _multiple_ new or existing email accounts./
> 
> I understand the need of being as clear as possible, but we should be 
> careful in not turning every single button into a paragraph. A good UI 
> is understandable without over explaining every single button.
> 
> Labels, titles, info tooltips, and descriptions, should be short and on 
> point, without being verbose and too long. Other than looking terrible 
> in the end result, too much copy will distract and overwhelm the user.
> 
> Also, asking questions is not recommended in general. If you open a 
> window with 3 buttons, you know you have to click on one of those. 
> Buttons already have labels to indicate what they do, therefor is not 
> necessary to ask "Which button do you want to click?". This is not a 
> questionnaire, but a guided setup dialog. We should present clear 
> solutions not open questions.
> 
> We should avoid designing for edge cases. Majority of users will write 
> their email and password and that's it. If tech savvy users need to 
> configure something manually, the "Set Up later" link to close the 
> dialog will give them the chance to do what they need to do.
> 
> Adding a "Manual configuration" button on first screen, or "Import 
> certificate", or something of this genre, will only increase complexity 
> and clutter the dialog for an option that is not commonly used. Once 
> again, we shouldn't design for edge cases.
> 
> The "Return here later..." is also unnecessary since the ability to 
> create new accounts will be easily accessible in TB, and this dialog 
> will always be used. We could play with the idea of having a final 
> screen where we offer 2 funnels "Done/Close" and "Set Up another 
> Account". The "Set Up later" link is explanatory enough to communicate 
> to the user that this is not a one time screen and they can access it at 
> a later time.
> 
>     /Sorry if this was already answered, will only the account setup see
>     an UI refreshment or whole of Thunderbird?/
> 
> This is a first step of an ongoing work that doesn't currently have a 
> release or end date. We will implement these changes slowly and 
> carefully, section by section, in order to make it right and not rush it.
> 
>     Option to use same credentials for outgoing as incoming
>     bug 543827 - https://bugzilla.mozilla.org/show_bug.cgi?id=543827
> 
>     I just threw together a mock-up adding two options and uploaded it to
>     the bug above but essentially, it just adds two lines below the
>     'Remember password' option, like this:
> 
>     [ ] Remember password
>     [x] Use only secure settings
>     [x] Use same settings for sending mail
> 
>     As pictured, i also think they (the two new options I am proposing)
>     should be enabled by default.
> 
> I wouldn't recommend this. TB should try to do all this in the 
> background (which I think it already does), and not offer users extra 
> options which are already checked by default so why we even put them there.
> 
> The manual configuration appears only if TB can't connect by trying all 
> the possible settings, and all the fields in the manual config will be 
> prepopulated with what TB finds on the server and what the user wrote.
> 
> *Closing thoughts*
> 
> I understand the feeling of "we should add *this* also because users 
> will use it", but we should be really careful about the amount of 
> buttons, labels, links, descriptions, checkboxes, etc. we want to add to 
> this dialog.
> 
> We need to offer a few and simple options, and guide the users where 
> they need to go, not try to put everything on the same screen. No matter 
> how slick and curated a UI can be, if it's cluttered with dozens of 
> options it will only overwhelm and confuse the user. We need to avoid that.
> 
> Not everything is a priority. Specific sections must be revealed only 
> when is necessary for the user to interact with them. Verbose and 
> descriptive messages should be optimized or replaced by intuitive 
> actions and icons.
> 
> Let's stay focus and not get sucked into the rabbit hole of adding every 
> possible option ever. Iterations and A/B testing will help us improve 
> everything we do.
> 
> Thank you again for your great work.
> 
> -- 
> *Alessandro Castellani*
> Lead UX Architect
> Thunderbird
> 
> _______________________________________________
> tb-planning mailing list
> tb-planning at mozilla.org
> https://mail.mozilla.org/listinfo/tb-planning
> 



-- 
"Catch the Magic of Linux..."
------------------------------------------------------------------------
Michael Peddemors, President/CEO LinuxMagic Inc.
Visit us at http://www.linuxmagic.com @linuxmagic
A Wizard IT Company - For More Info http://www.wizard.ca
"LinuxMagic" a Registered TradeMark of Wizard Tower TechnoServices Ltd.
------------------------------------------------------------------------
604-682-0300 Beautiful British Columbia, Canada

This email and any electronic data contained are confidential and intended
solely for the use of the individual or entity to which they are addressed.
Please note that any views or opinions presented in this email are solely
those of the author and are not intended to represent those of the company.


More information about the tb-planning mailing list