Thunderbird Council Election 2019: Results

John Bieling john.bieling at gmx.de
Wed Mar 20 23:49:51 UTC 2019


Can we get more details?

Like what is the threshold used and what are the exact voting results,
including the second and third preferences, so the vote transfer can be
understood?

What I find strange for example: Of the 16 voters for Philipp Kewisch as
first preference, only 5 had a second preference (so 11 voters only
voted for Philipp K and no other candidate at all?) and all of those 5
voters picked Magnus as second preference? There is no distribution on
the second preference in that case? Same later on with all the other
transfers?

Thanks,
John



On 21.03.2019 00:12, Don Marti wrote:
> OpaVote Election Results (https://www.OpaVote.com/)
>
> Thunderbird Council Election 2019
>
> There are 11 candidates competing for 7 seats. The number of voters is 81 and
> there were 80 valid votes and 1 empty votes.
>
> Counting votes using Scottish STV.
>
>   R|Ryan Sipes|Philipp Ke|Philippe L|Magnus Mel|Elio Qoshi|Patrick Cl|Joed Lopez
>    |          |wisch     |ieser     |in        |          |oke       |
>    |----------------------------------------------------------------------------
>    |Wayne Mery|Ben Bucksc|Jörg Knobl|Berna Alp |Exhausted |Surplus   |Threshold
>    |          |h         |och       |          |          |          |
> ===============================================================================
>   1|  14.00000|  16.00000|   0.00000|  10.00000|   2.00000|   4.00000|   0.00000
>    |  13.00000|   2.00000|  14.00000|   5.00000|   0.00000|  13.00000|  11.00000
>    |----------------------------------------------------------------------------
>    | Count of first choices. Candidates Ryan Sipes, Philipp Kewisch, Wayne Mery,
>    | and Jörg Knobloch have reached the threshold and are elected. Candidates
>    | have surplus votes so surplus votes will be transferred for the next round.
> ===============================================================================
>   2|  14.00000|  11.00000|   0.00000|  13.12500|   2.31250|   4.62500|   0.00000
>    |  13.00000|   2.93750|  14.00000|   5.00000|   0.00000|  10.12500|  11.00000
>    |----------------------------------------------------------------------------
>    | Count after transferring surplus votes from Philipp Kewisch with a transfer
>    | value of 5.00000/16.00000. Candidate Magnus Melin has reached the threshold
>    | and is elected. Candidates have surplus votes so surplus votes will be
>    | transferred for the next round.
> ===============================================================================
>   3|  11.00000|  11.00000|   0.00000|  13.12500|   2.95534|   6.33924|   0.42856
>    |  13.00000|   2.93750|  14.00000|   5.21428|   0.00008|   7.12500|  11.00000
>    |----------------------------------------------------------------------------
>    | Count after transferring surplus votes from Ryan Sipes with a transfer
>    | value of 3.00000/14.00000. Candidates Ryan Sipes and Jörg Knobloch were
>    | tied when choosing surplus to transfer. Candidate Ryan Sipes was chosen by
>    | breaking the tie randomly. Candidates have surplus votes so surplus votes
>    | will be transferred for the next round.
> ===============================================================================
>   4|  11.00000|  11.00000|   0.21428|  13.12500|   3.16962|   6.33924|   0.64284
>    |  13.00000|   3.58034|  11.00000|   6.07140|   0.85728|   4.12500|  11.00000
>    |----------------------------------------------------------------------------
>    | Count after transferring surplus votes from Jörg Knobloch with a transfer
>    | value of 3.00000/14.00000. Candidates have surplus votes so surplus votes
>    | will be transferred for the next round.
> ===============================================================================
>   5|  11.00000|  11.00000|   0.37618|  11.00000|   3.16962|   7.71536|   0.64284
>    |  13.00000|   3.84342|  11.00000|   6.07140|   1.18118|   2.00000|  11.00000
>    |----------------------------------------------------------------------------
>    | Count after transferring surplus votes from Magnus Melin with a transfer
>    | value of 2.12500/13.12500. Candidates have surplus votes so surplus votes
>    | will be transferred for the next round.
> ===============================================================================
>   6|  11.00000|  11.00000|   0.37618|  11.00000|   3.16962|   8.94608|   0.64284
>    |  11.00000|   4.30494|  11.00000|   6.22524|   1.33510|   0.00000|  11.00000
>    |----------------------------------------------------------------------------
>    | Count after transferring surplus votes from Wayne Mery with a transfer
>    | value of 2.00000/13.00000. No candidates have surplus votes so candidates
>    | will be eliminated and their votes transferred for the next round.
> ===============================================================================
>   7|  11.00000|  11.00000|          |  11.00000|   3.16962|   9.16036|   0.64284
>    |  11.00000|   4.30494|  11.00000|   6.38714|   1.33510|   0.00000|  11.00000
>    |----------------------------------------------------------------------------
>    | Count after eliminating Philippe Lieser and transferring votes. No
>    | candidates have surplus votes so candidates will be eliminated and their
>    | votes transferred for the next round.
> ===============================================================================
>   8|  11.00000|  11.00000|          |  11.00000|   3.59818|   9.37464|
>    |  11.00000|   4.30494|  11.00000|   6.38714|   1.33510|   0.00000|  11.00000
>    |----------------------------------------------------------------------------
>    | Count after eliminating Joed Lopez and transferring votes. No candidates
>    | have surplus votes so candidates will be eliminated and their votes
>    | transferred for the next round.
> ===============================================================================
>   9|  11.00000|  11.00000|          |  11.00000|          |  10.54426|
>    |  11.00000|   5.73350|  11.00000|   7.38714|   1.33510|   0.00000|  11.00000
>    |----------------------------------------------------------------------------
>    | Count after eliminating Elio Qoshi and transferring votes. No candidates
>    | have surplus votes so candidates will be eliminated and their votes
>    | transferred for the next round.
> ===============================================================================
> 10|  11.00000|  11.00000|          |  11.00000|          |  11.80549|
>    |  11.00000|          |  11.00000|  11.49129|   1.70322|   1.29678|  11.00000
>    |----------------------------------------------------------------------------
>    | Count after eliminating Ben Bucksch and transferring votes. Candidates
>    | Patrick Cloke and Berna Alp have reached the threshold and are elected.
>
> Winners are Ryan Sipes, Philipp Kewisch, Magnus Melin, Patrick Cloke, Wayne
> Mery, Jörg Knobloch, and Berna Alp.
>
> _______________________________________________
> tb-planning mailing list
> tb-planning at mozilla.org
> https://mail.mozilla.org/listinfo/tb-planning

-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <http://mail.mozilla.org/pipermail/tb-planning/attachments/20190321/3ccfea60/attachment-0001.html>


More information about the tb-planning mailing list