TB24 inclusion for new minor feature (thread-sorting pref)

Magnus Melin mkmelin+mozilla at iki.fi
Mon Aug 12 06:01:26 UTC 2013


I'd set the approval-comm-aurora and beta flags, and hope for the best :)
It's a fairly small patch with no localization changes so landing it for 24 
shouldn't be out of the question.

  -Magnus

On 12.8.2013 02:18, The Wanderer wrote:
> Since it's so late in the TB24 release process, it's been suggested that
> I bring this up here, rather than just requesting approval-comm-aurora
> (or would that be approval-comm-beta by now?) on the relevant bug. If
> that's the wrong approach, please let me know, and I can submit
> whichever request would be appropriate there for whatever discussion
> might be needed.
>
>
> I would like to see the fix for bug 495946 (a pref to allow threads to
> be sorted by the date of the root message, rather than the newest one)
> make it into the TB24 "full release" / ESR, either as part of the
> initial release, or as part of one of the subsequent point releases.
>
> It is not a fix for a crash or other stability problem, or for a
> security hole; it is technically a fix for a regression, but the
> regression occurred in the transition from Thunderbird 2 to Thunderbird
> 3, so it can't be considered urgent on that basis. It fixes the
> regression not by restoring the exact old behavior, but by implementing
> new functionality which improves on the original behavior.
>
> I personally consider the behavior which regressed to be absolutely
> essential, to the extent that I have remained on Thunderbird 2 to date
> rather than migrate to a version without it. However, I appear to be
> distinctly in the minority in that regard.
>
> There do not appear to be any existing tests which cover thread sorting
> order per se, but all existing tests which cover message sorting at all
> appear to pass with this fix included. The introduced behavior is also
> off by default (behind a pref which defaults to false), so the fix
> should not change anything for anyone who doesn't want to change it.
>
>
> The reason I would like to see this included in the TB24 ESR is that the
> ESR is now the basis of the Thunderbird variant provided by my Linux
> distribution (Debian); if this is not included in the TB24 ESR, I will
> not see it through my distro until the TB31 ESR, a good year away.
>
> In the absence of a distro-provided version which includes the fix, my
> only options would be to A: maintain it as a patch against the distro
> version, B: run a non-distro-managed Thunderbird, or C: continue to
> remain on TB2. None of these is desirable.
>
>
> I recognize that the odds of this getting accepted for inclusion in the
> TB24 ESR release at this point are very slim, but they're even slimmer
> if I don't even ask for it. So, I'm asking: what would the prospects for
> getting this included in the TB24 ESR release line (whether initially or
> in a point release) be? More to the point, who would I have to convince,
> and what sort of thing would it take to be convincing?
>



More information about the tb-planning mailing list