Typeof this in getters (was: eval on non-strings)

Domenic Denicola domenic at domenicdenicola.com
Tue Feb 28 15:38:31 PST 2012

Both IE10 Developer Preview (10.0.8102.0) and IE10 Platform Preview 4 (10.0.8103.0) output

    number      object
    object        object

We'll see if tomorrow's drop does any better.

Sounds like I should file test262 bugs as well.

From: Mark S. Miller [mailto:erights at google.com] 
Sent: Tuesday, February 28, 2012 14:38
To: Domenic Denicola
Cc: Allen Wirfs-Brock; Brendan Eich; es-discuss at mozilla.org
Subject: Re: Typeof this in getters (was: eval on non-strings)

I like the output display on http://jsfiddle.net/CxdMs/16/ a bit better. I just tried it on very recent versions of 4 or the 5 major browsers. I was shocked to see that all of them were wrong.

Correct would be

    number      number
    object        object

Chrome 19 gave

    number      number
    object        number

Opera 12, Safari WebKit 5.1.3 (7534.53.10, r109097), and Mozilla FF Nightly 13 all gave

    number      object
    object        object

What does the latest IE10 preview do?

Domenic, as you post bugs against the browsers, please send me the URLs. Thanks.

On Tue, Feb 28, 2012 at 10:03 AM, Domenic Denicola <domenic at domenicdenicola.com> wrote:
> Specifically regarding ToObject.  It's use is important in minimizing the semantic differences between primitive values and Objects. In ES5 we eliminated the automatic wrapping of primitive values  used as this values in method invocations.  That means that in most cases 42 and (new Number(42)) can be used interchangeably. If we start leaving out ToObject calls in random places the distinction between a primitive value and a wrapped primitive values will start tripping people up.

This actually is apropos of something I'd been meaning to ask about. Consider the following JSFiddle:


It seems reasonably clear that the result for functions should be object (non-strict)/number (strict), according to section 10.4.3.

But for getters, the major browsers disagree, and my spec-fu can't find anything besides the abovementioned section. Firefox and IE9 say object/object, while V8 says number/number. And at least one version of JavaScriptCore we have lying around says number/object. If someone could walk me through the spec correctly, I'd be happy to file appropriate browser bugs.

Note that this is a real-world issue. The Chai.js assertion library is trying to break free of V8 and become useful in browsers, but is encountering problems due to this behavior:


Thanks all,
es-discuss mailing list
es-discuss at mozilla.org


More information about the es-discuss mailing list